在美国财产法中,adverse possession是一个非常有意思的概念。
具体而言,adverse possession(敌对占有,逆权占有)是指非所有人通过对所有人的不动产进行(1)排他的、(2)持续的、未被中断的、(3)公开的、(4)可见的,并且(5)与所有人权利相敌对的占有,(6)达到一定期间,从而排出所有人的产权,对所占有的不动产取得产权的制度。
构成要件如下:
Exclusive use
Continuous use
Open and notorious possession
A hostile takeover of the property
Actual possession
For a certain period of time
法律为什么要保护一个侵占他人财产的侵权人,而不保护真实的所有人?
Homes大法官(美国)认为,“一件事物,你当作自己的财产使用了很长一段时间,不论是财产还是观点,不管你是怎么得到的,都根植于你,移走它不可能不遭到你的反对或防卫。”所以,如果一个人忽视行使其权利,他就不能在一定时间后指责侵权人对自己财产的占有。
需要注意的是,Adverse possession在很大程度上与大陆法系的时效取得相似,但基于两大法系的体系性差异,两者在指导理论、适用客体和构成要件等问题上都有所不同,因此不能简单的等量视之。
根据美国多年来的判例发展,敌对占有制度具有以下特点:
1. 占有的客观要素越来越重要,已经成为敌对占有制度的核心,占有人的主观状态反而不重要,即侵占人的主观意图(敌意性)不是必须的。
2. 占有的期限有缩短的趋势。在美国许多州的判例法中,敌对占有的法定期限曾经是40年,现在已降至20年~15年。
LEC真题演练
A field, owned by the city, was used as a municipal parking lot for many years. When a new parking facility was constructed, the field was no longer used for that purpose. A parcel of land constituting a small portion of the field at the easterly end was never officially vacated by the municipality. Lee, the adjoining owner on both sides of the field, went into possession of the parcel, fenced it, and cultivated the parcel for a period of time in excess of the period required for adverse possession.
In an appropriate action brought by Lee to establish his title to the parcel, which of the following must he establish if he is to prevail?
I. Real property interests can be lost by a municipality by adverse possession.
II. His use of the parcel was proof of his assertion of dominion over the parcel.
III. Fee interests in real property can be abandoned by a municipality without an official vote.
IV. Lack of use of the parcel by the municipality created an irrevocable license in him.
A. I and II only. B. I and IV only.
C. II and III only. D. III and IV only.
参考答案:A
温馨提示:
2021年上半年的LEC考试,正在火热报名中。报名时间3月1日0时至3月31日24时,请登录LEC官网<www.lectest.com>,及时报名。
查看考试公告请点击:2021年上半年法律英语证书(LEC)全国统一考试公告
关注LEC资讯号,最新动态尽知!